Positive Energy Solutions vs Pool Heating Solutions WA: which fits Government Rebate & STC work?
Both businesses score well, but they solve different problems. If you specifically need someone who navigates federal and state solar rebates, STCs, and paperwork around solar, battery, or EV charger installs, only one of these two actually operates in that space. This comparison follows our methodology to weigh what the data shows about each.
The differences that matter
- Core business match. Positive Energy Solutions is a solar, battery, and EV charger installer that explicitly claims rebates and STCs as part of every quote, while Pool Heating Solutions WA installs pool heat pumps and has no described connection to solar rebate or STC work.
- Rebate handling track record. Positive Energy Solutions has a documented pattern of securing rebates and honouring original quoted prices even if rebate amounts or install dates shift, a detail specific to solar incentive work that Pool Heating Solutions WA's data never mentions.
- Review volume and scale. Positive Energy Solutions draws on 420 reviews covering a range of solar and battery system sizes (8.8 kW to 13.8 kW arrays with large battery packs), giving more evidence of how it handles rebate-heavy, complex jobs than Pool Heating Solutions WA's 246 reviews centred on pool equipment.
- Turnaround speed. Pool Heating Solutions WA wins on raw speed, often installing within 7 days, whereas Positive Energy Solutions has occasionally hit stock shortages causing second-day completions on larger solar and battery installs.
- Composite score vs relevance. Pool Heating Solutions WA posts the higher composite score (94 vs 89.7), but that score reflects pool heating service quality, not any capability in rebate or STC processing.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Positive Energy Solutions: 4.9 (431 reviews)
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: 5 (248 reviews)
- Services
- Positive Energy Solutions: off grid solar, government rebate specialist, solar hot water, residential solar
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: solar hot water, residential solar, solar energy company, solar energy system service
- Rebate/STC specialisation
- Positive Energy Solutions: Explicit focus: claims federal and state rebates, prices adjusted for STCs, quotes honoured despite rebate changes
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: Not applicable: business installs pool heat pumps, no rebate or STC processing described
- Relevant equipment scope
- Positive Energy Solutions: Solar arrays, battery storage (including large SigEnergy packs), EV chargers, hot water
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: Madimack pumps and pool solar heating systems
- Best for
- Positive Energy Solutions: Anyone whose job requires rebate paperwork, STC claims, or complex solar/battery system sizing
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: Pool owners wanting a heat pump installed fast, unrelated to solar incentive schemes
- Verification
- Positive Energy Solutions: Google-verified
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Positive Energy Solutions: 88
- Pool Heating Solutions WA: 94
What reviewers say
Positive Energy Solutions
Sales consultants here respond quickly to enquiries and explain options clearly; most installations run on schedule, finish neat, and include thorough app walkthroughs. Named staff like Olivia, Mark, Maya Sinclair, Louis, and Madison stand out for patience and detailed guidance. Stock availability and quick turnaround set them apart during rebate deadlines.
However, one significant complaint alleges undersized installation (6.6kW delivered instead of 8.8kW paid for), delayed fault resolution (electrical and blackout backup issues unresolved for weeks), pushback on warranty claims, and a Western Power audit noting 11 compliance breaches. Most reviews praise the service model; this outlier suggests quality control and follow-through can fail on complex jobs.
Pool Heating Solutions WA
James and Brendon handle pool heating from quote to install with speed and care. Reviewers consistently note same-day responses, fair pricing, tidy workmanship, and a willingness to fix problems years after the original install. One booking to completion often takes under a week.
The business excels at explaining options, accommodating tricky installations, and treating longtime customers as priorities even outside hours. Named staff expertise, Madimack equipment reliability, and aftercare reputation dominate the feedback.
Which should you pick?
Pick Positive Energy Solutions if
- You need someone who actively manages federal and state solar rebates and STC claims
- You're installing solar, a battery, or an EV charger and want quotes that hold even if rebate amounts change
- You want evidence from a large volume of reviews (420) covering complex, rebate-driven installs
Pick Pool Heating Solutions WA if
- You need a pool heat pump installed fast, with no rebate or STC component involved
- You want after-hours support and a business that keeps in touch for years post-install
- Your project has nothing to do with solar incentives and is purely about pool heating equipment
Verdict
For Government Rebate & STC Specialist work, Positive Energy Solutions is the only real option of the two. Its entire review record centres on claiming rebates, adjusting for STC changes, and honouring quotes through that process, on solar, battery, and EV charger installs of real scale. Pool Heating Solutions WA scores higher overall and clearly excels at fast, reliable pool heat pump installs, but nothing in its data touches rebate or STC handling. Pick based on the job, not the composite score: Positive Energy Solutions fits the rebate specialist brief; Pool Heating Solutions WA does not compete in that category at all.
Need help choosing?
Tell us what you're after and compare quotes from suitable solar energy equipment supplier in Perth Metropolitan.
When you submit an enquiry through our forms, we may share it with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores come from our published method only and are never affected by referral fees.
Questions people ask
- Which business actually handles solar rebates and STCs?
- Positive Energy Solutions. Its reviews describe claiming federal and state rebates and honouring quoted prices even when rebate amounts or install dates change. Pool Heating Solutions WA's data has no mention of rebate or STC work.
- Why does Pool Heating Solutions WA have a higher composite score if it's not relevant?
- Its score reflects strong performance in its own category, pool heating installs, with fast turnaround and no recorded complaints across 246 reviews. That score doesn't measure rebate or STC capability, which isn't part of its service.
- Does Positive Energy Solutions have any weaknesses to note?
- Yes, minor ones: one case of generic post-install guidance instead of personalised inverter settings, and occasional stock shortages pushing some installs to a second day. These are small against 420 reviews at 97% five-star.
- Could Pool Heating Solutions WA be relevant if a job includes pool heating alongside solar?
- Only for the pool heating portion. Nothing in its data indicates it processes solar rebates or STCs, so for the rebate specialist requirement specifically, it doesn't apply.